If you love to bake cookies, one of the most fun kitchen utensils you can get to help you make cute cookies has to be a cookie press.
And there’s certainly no shortage of cookie presses on the market today!
We’ve been checking out some of the best, and after much deliberation, we were able to pick out a few of our favorites that we’re going to review for you here today.
We’ve been looking into some top brands, including the likes of Oxo, Cuisinart, and Wilton. More on these later.
First, we’re going to kick things off with a quick comparison table before laying out the key criteria we used for assessment and comparison.
Our in-depth product reviews will follow, and then we’ll top things off with a section where we answer some of your most frequently asked questions on the subject.
So, without further ado, let’s get straight to it.
Cookie Presses Bestseller List
Comparison Table
Key Criteria For Assessment And Comparison
Number of Discs Included
The more discs you have with your cookie press, the greater the variety of cookies that you can make with it, making it a much more versatile product, and it really opens up the possibilities of what you can do with it.
You should also look into whether it has designs that you would actually use. And preferably ones that you can use again and again, to get a really good lifespan from the product.
Made of Good Quality Materials and Parts
It’s important that you look for a cookie press that’s made to last. And that means parts that won’t rust. You can make do ok with plastic materials and parts, but if you can get a stainless steel set-up, that would be even better.
Ergonomic and Easy to Use
If you intend to make big batches of cookies at a time or several batches, then you’re going to need a cookie press that is easy to work with and comfortable to use for long periods of time.
Easy to Clean
As with any culinary utensil, you’re going to have to clean the cookie press after every use, so anything that helps make this process easy is a plus in our book.
Value for Money
Cookie presses can really vary somewhat in price. You can get some for as little as about $10, but at the other end of the spectrum, they can cost as much as $50. So we recommend that you check all the prices as you go along.
Best Cookie Press
1. Best Overall Cookie Press: OXO Good Grips Cookie Press with Stainless Steel Disks and Storage Case
How It Stands Up Against the Comparison Criteria
- Number of Discs Included - The Oxo Good Grips cookie press comes with a total of 12 disks, and they’re very cute ones at that. They include heart, flower, snowflake tree, leaf, and butterfly shapes, so there’s plenty of variety there.
- Made of Good Quality Materials and Parts - This cookie press is composed of both plastic and metal parts. The disks are made of stainless steel, which means that you don’t have to worry about them rusting at all.
- Ergonomic and Easy to Use - The Oxo brand is known for producing utensils with good, ergonomic grips, and this cookie press is no exception to the rule.
- Easy to Clean - The clear cylinder where you load up your cookie dough disassembles very easily for cleaning, and better yet, the parts are all dishwasher safe to boot.
- Value for Money - The Oxo Good Grips cookie press has earned the title of Amazon’s Choice in the category of cookie presses. Such a title is only given to products that are both of excellent quality and available at a good and reasonable price.
Manufacturer Background
The Oxo brand has been around for circa 30 years now and is headquartered in New York.
The vision began when the founder, Sam Farber, saw his wife struggle to use regular kitchen utensils when she came down with arthritis, and he sought to develop kitchen tools with more comfortable handles.
As a result of this, 15 Oxo Good Grips kitchen tools were launched, including the OXO Good Grips Cookie Press. That was in 1990.
Oxo has oodles of confidence in the quality of their products, which is why they’re happy to back them all by no questions asked money-back guarantee. So, if you weren’t 100% happy with your purchase, you can get a free replacement or refund.
But that’s by no means the only reason to buy from Oxo. They are partnered with 1% for the planet, and they donate a full 1% of their annual sales to charitable organizations that seek to improve the environment.
And more recently, the Oxo brand has donated over $2.5 million to Cookies for Kids Cancer.
Why is this the best overall cookie press?
As we mentioned earlier, The Oxo brand is known for producing utensils with good, ergonomic grips, and this cookie press is no exception to the rule.
Pressing out the cookie dough onto a baking sheet is light work with this cookie press. It’s a breeze to work with.
But that’s not all it’s got going for it. We just adore the different patterned cookies you can make with this set - pretty butterflies and flowers and snowflakes. And when it comes to decorating them, you can really go to town!
And the fact that all the parts are dishwasher safe is a huge bonus!
We also love the fact that it comes with a storage case for the stainless steel discs - you could lose a disc or two very easily otherwise.
Also, the product is also backed by Oxo’s money-back customer satisfaction guarantee, so you have nothing to lose by buying it.
Experience of Using the Product
When this article was written, this cookie press was THE number one bestseller with the leading online retailers in the category of cookie presses, and there have been well over 5,000 individual customer ratings for it on Amazon alone.
Better yet, after so many individual customer ratings, the average rating comes out at an impressive 4 and a half stars out of 5, which is thanks to three-quarters of customers giving it a full 5 stars rating.
They also rated it at 4 and a half stars for a number of different features. These are as follows: easy to assemble, easy to clean, ergonomic, easy to use, giftable, and durable.
Customer reviews typically say things like it’s easy to use, it’s easy to clean, it’s highly recommended, and that it’s much easier to use than alternative brand cookie presses.
Pros
- A top bestseller with retailers
- 12 really nice disc shapes
- Storage box for the discs
- Particularly easy to use
- Excellent product quality
Cons
- Some customers have said that getting the cookies perfect takes a little practice
- Creates consistent cookies with the press of a lever
- Durable, stainless steel disks in 12 classic and custom designs
- Non-slip base keeps Cookie Press steady
- Clear body shows how much dough is left
- Large, non-slip lever is comfortable for repetitive use
2. Best Multipurpose Cookie Press: Cuisinart Cookie Press with 18 Discs and 6 Decorating Tips
How It Stands Up Against the Comparison Criteria
- The number of discs included - There are a whopping 18 discs included with the cookie press. These include all the numbers from 0 through to 9, which makes it perfect for making cookies for a child’s birthday party. There’s also some nice flower designs, a heart and a tree. In addition to the discs, there are also 6 decorating tips.
- Made of Good Quality Materials and Parts - As you may have come to expect from Cuisinart, their cookie press is of excellent quality.
- Ergonomic and Easy to Use - One of the things we love about this cookie press is just how ergonomic and easy to use it is. Once you’ve got the cookie dough in place in the see-through cylinder, you simply attach the remaining parts. The handle of the gadget conforms to the shape of your fingers, and you simply squeeze the trigger with your hand to push out the cookie dough.
- Easy to Clean - The gadget will disassemble easily for cleaning, and better yet, all the parts are entirely dishwasher safe - so convenient.
- Value for Money - Amazon occasionally has deals on this particular cookie press, simply click on “Check price” to see if there’s a deal on now.
Manufacturer Background
The Cuisinart brand dates back to 1973, so is very well established. It really took off when they started releasing food processors. But since then they have expanded to produce a great number of top quality products.
Not just in the field of food processors and blenders, but across the entire remit of kitchen appliances and utensils.
Today, Cuisinart has become a household name and a brand that you can trust. Their mission is to help their customers “Savor the Good Life®” They are partnered with a number of causes related to keeping culinary education alive and well, as well as some more well known charities, like The Breast Cancer Research Foundation®.
Why is this the best multipurpose cookie press?
Not only has Cuisinart made an excellent little cookie press, but this cookie press also doubles as a piping kit for decorating cakes and cookies.
All you have to do is replace the discs with one of the accompanying decorating tips, and scoop the frosting into the gadget instead of cookie dough, and you get really pretty frosting designs.
And, in addition to using it to make cookies, you can also use it to make chalis, which are savory snacks made with fried dough. And it has savory uses too - you can use it to fill deviled eggs or pasta shells.
And besides that, it’s also a good cookie press all around. It’s see-through, so you can see how much dough is left. And the size of it is universal, which means that you can use it with other discs if you wanted to. Holiday discs are very popular. And it’s all dishwasher safe, which is a dream.
And if you’re a beginner to cookie making, the included recipe booklet comes in pretty handy too.
But that’s not all. Cuisinart has backed up this product with a limited lifetime warranty. This means that if you were to have any issues with it, they’ll be happy to help out, no matter how long it’s been since the date of purchase.
Experience of Using the Product
After well over 200 individual customer ratings on Amazon, the average customer rating is 4 stars out of 5, thanks to more than 60% of customers giving it a full 5 stars rating.
It was also rated quite highly for a number of features, including being easy to clean, being easy to use, and being good value for money.
Customer reviews typically say that the cookie press works great, is very easy to use, and is easy to clean. Customers also talk about how handy it is for decorating with as well, thanks to the inclusion of the decorating tips.
Pros
- Doubles as a piping kit!
- Great for children’s parties
- Comfortable & ergonomic
- Parts are dishwasher safe
- Limited lifetime warranty
Cons
- The customer reviews are quite mixed, they’re not all positive and glowing
- Cookie press includes 18 design discs and 6 decorating tips
- Makes cookies in minutes
- Recipe booklet included
- Dishwasher safe
- Limited lifetime warrranty
3. Best Budget Cookie Press: Wilton Simple Success Cookie Press
How It Stands Up Against the Comparison Criteria
- Number of discs included - There are a total of 13 discs included in the kit, including a heart design, a pumpkin, a Christmas tree, a wreath, flowers, a snowman, a peacock (well it says it's a turkey but to me, it looks like a peacock), and several other really cute designs.
- Made of Good Quality Materials and Parts - Despite the bargain, affordable price, Wilton has not had to compromise on the quality of the product’s parts.
- Ergonomic and Easy to Use - The Wilton Simple Success Cookie Press is remarkably comfortable and easy to use. Once everything is in place, you simply squeeze your hand closed over the handle, and the perfect amount of cookie dough comes out, to give you consistent results.
- Easy to Clean - It’s easy to disassemble, and once you have, all the parts are dishwasher safe.
- Value for Money - This budget buy is excellent value for money - especially if you manage to catch one of Amazon’s occasional deals, simply click on “check price” to see if there’s a deal on now.
Manufacturer Background
The Wilton brand is now very well established, having been around in one form or another for the last 90 years or so. And where it stands out against other makers of kitchen utensils, is how their sole focus is just on the sorts of products involved in baking, cake decorating, parties and the like.
They have a strong focus on customer experience, and they develop innovative tools to help bring out the best results for budding bakers and cake decorators.
Their product remit includes bakeware, tools, ingredients, and display and storage. And as well as products, they also provide the consumer with an array of accessible projects and recipes.
The brand also appears to be charitable. On their website, they state that they build on their “sweet credibility” through the giving of their service, products, and employee fundraising, though it does not state specifically what charities they support. They also offer baking and cake decorating classes.
Why is this the best budget cookie press?
The stand-out feature of the Wilton Simple Success Cookie Press has to be its bargain, affordable price point. If you manage to catch one of Amazon’s occasional deals, you may be able to pick one up for under $10. And that’s a mere fraction of what you’d normally expect to pay for a cookie press.
And even if you don’t manage to catch a deal, it’s still excellent value for money.
And there’s no compromise in the making of this cookie press. It’s still of good quality, is easy and ergonomic to use, is dishwasher safe, and it comes with some really nice cookie press discs. You can make up some really pretty cookies with it.
Experience of Using the Product
After well over 3,000 individual customer reviews on Amazon, the average customer rating comes out quite high at 4 stars out of 5. This is thanks to more than 60% of customers rating it at a full 5 stars.
They rated it at 4 stars for being easy to clean and good value for money. And they rated it at 3 and a half stars for being giftable, easy to use, and sheer. Unfortunately, they only rated it at 3 stars out of 5 for durability.
Customer reviews typically say things like it’s super easy to use and to clean, and that it’s really fun to use.
Pros
- Available at a bargain price
- All parts are dishwasher safe
- Ergonomic and Easy to Use
- Comes with 13 pretty discs
Cons
- The customer reviews are quite mixed, they’re not all positive and glowing
- Make fast and easy uniform spritz cookies for a crowd
- Comfortable ergonomic handle with soft-grip trigger
- Clear barrel so you can see how much dough you have
- Includes 12 discs in versatile shapes, including seasonal favorites: Christmas tree, wreath and snowman, pumpkin, turkey and everyday designs: dot pattern, doily, pinwheel, heart, starburst, sunburst and biscuit
- Before first and after each use, wash in warm, soapy water; Rinse and dry thoroughly
Frequently Asked Questions
We would argue that the best cookie press out on the market at the moment is the Oxo Good Grips cookie press. It comes from a brand known for its good, ergonomic grips, and even people with arthritis can use it comfortably.
It’s THE number one bestseller with the leading online retailers and comes with 12 really nice discs, with their very own storage case. And all the parts are dishwasher safe to boot.
Join the Discussion