If you are wanting to make the perfect muffin but are struggling to create the iconic shape then you will need a muffin pan. Separated into cavities, muffin pans can help you to create muffins that look more consistent as well as allow them to be baked throughout evenly.
Knowing which muffin pan is the best one for you can be difficult as there are thousands of options on the market. We’ve gathered the top five muffin pans on the market followed by an exclusive Buyers Guide and FAQ so you know what to look out for when conducting your own research.
Jump to:
Muffin Pan Bestsellers
Here are the top five muffin pans on the market that you should consider:
Comparison Table
Best Muffin Pan
1. USA Pan Bakeware Cupcake and Muffin Pan
Our top recommendation is the USA Pan Bakeware Cupcake and Muffin Pan which features twelve standard-size wells.
Made from commercial grade and heavy gauge aluminized steel, this muffin pan is durable and reliable, guaranteed to withstand years of heavy-duty use.
With an Americoat over the steel, this pan promotes the quick release of baked goods plus fast and easy clean-up by washing with hot water and mild soap, making it ideal for those who want a pan that is low maintenance.
The nonstick Americoat coating is a patented silicone coating that is PTFE, PFOA, and BPA free which means that you get the best from both metal and silicone qualities.
What makes this our top pick is that USA Pan has been one of the industry’s leading brands for over 50 years and can always be trusted to make products of the highest quality.
They guarantee 100% customer satisfaction which is highlighted by the returns policy that they have provided with this muffin pan. It comes with a lifetime warranty so you can be assured that you are going to be using it for years to come.
Pros
- Made from commercial grade and heavy gauge aluminized steel, this muffin pan is durable and reliable, guaranteed to withstand years of heavy duty use
- With an Americoat over the steel, this pan promotes the quick release of baked goods plus fast and easy clean up by washing with hot water and mild soap, making it ideal for those who want a pan that is low maintenance
- Comes with a lifetime warranty so you can be assured that you are going to be using it for years to come
Cons
- High price point
- USA Pan baking pans feature Americoat which promotes quick release of baked-goods plus fast and easy clean up; wash with hot water, mild soap and gentle scrub brush or sponge
- Nonstick Americoat coating - a patented silicone coating which is PTFE, PFOA and BPA free - provides quick and easy release of all baked-goods and minimal easy clean up
- Made in the USA; each cup measures 2.75 x 2.13 x 1.38 inch
- USA Pan is a Bundy family company which has proudly manufactured high quality bakeware and provided jobs in the USA for over 50 years
2. Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware Standard Muffin and Cupcake Pan
Our second selection is the Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware Standard Muffin and Cupcake Pan which features twelve cups so you can easily bake batches of muffins. This versatile pan can be used for other sweet treats other than muffins meaning that it is a must have for the avid baker.
Made from steel, this muffin pan is extremely durable and allows for even heating and is resistant to warping. The high quality material means that this pan has been designed for years of heavy duty use and also doesn’t transfer any odor or metallic taste from the pan to the food.
The surface of this muffin pan is non-stick which allows for easy release and quick cleanup as it helps to reduce mess as well as lessening the chances of the muffins breaking as you take them out of the tray.
Ideal for those who want a low maintenance product, this pan is dishwasher safe but for the best results, it is advised to wash in warm, soapy water by hand.
This pan also comes with a limited 10 year warranty so you can be assured of the high quality and have extra peace of mind. Wilton’s customer service team is always on hand to assist should you need it.
Pros
- Made from steel, this muffin pan is extremely durable and allows for even heating and is resistant to warping
- Ideal for those who want a low maintenance product, this pan is dishwasher safe but for the best results, it is advised to wash in warm, soapy water by hand
- Comes with a limited 10 year warranty so you can be assured of the high quality and have extra peace of mind
Cons
- Surface is easily scratched
- READY, SET, BAKE: Everyone loves a good, warm muffin in the morning, and it's never been easier than with this 12-cup non-stick muffin pan. This pan can also be used to make a dozen cupcakes to brighten someone's day
- BAKEWARE FOR EVERY DAY AND EVERY OCCASION: The muffin pan and cupcake pan from Wilton can bake batches of muffins or cupcakes in this 12-cup pan. Made of steel; reinforced non-stick coating for easy release and quick cleanup
- NON- STICK: No matter what you're making, the durable non-stick and scratch-resistant coating on our muffin and cupcake pans allows your food to slide or pop out easily, making cleanup almost effortless
- CARE INSTRUCTIONS: The Wilton muffin pan & cupcake pan is dishwasher safe; however for best results, wash in warm, soapy water before first and after each use
- INCLUDES: 1 muffin and cupcake pan, dimensions: 10.5 x 15 in. (26.6 x 38.1 cm); Cavity size: 2 in. dia. x 1.25 in. (5 cm diam x 3.2 cm). Limited 10-year warranty
3. Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick 6-Cup Standard Muffin Pan
Our third choice is the Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick 6-Cup Standard Muffin Pan which is ideal for those who have a stricter budget and don’t want a metal pan.
Made from silver plated plastic, this pan features a non-stick coating which allows for quick release to reduce any breakage when removing the muffins. The convenient handles have been designed for easy handling when taking the pan in and out of the oven.
The large six cavities mean that you are more likely to have equally portioned muffins that shape really well and are baked evenly throughout while the tray can withstand the heat and prevents any warping over time.
This is the best choice for those who want to make larger muffins as it comes with six large cavities. With two in the pack, you can make a dozen at a time for extra convenience.
This tray is dishwasher safe but it is best to wash in warm water with soap before and after each use so it lasts even longer and gives the ideal results each time.
Pros
- The convenient handles have been designed for easy handling when taking the pan in and out of the oven
- The large six cavities mean that you are more likely to have equally portioned muffins that shape really well and are baked evenly throughout while the tray can withstand the heat and prevents any warping
- This tray is dishwasher safe but it is best to wash in warm water with soap before and after each use so it lasts even longer and gives the ideal results each time
Cons
- Can be tricky to clean
- READY, SET, BAKE: Make more delicious muffins or cupcakes at a time with this convenient set of Wilton muffin pans. Great to have on hand any time you need to make a batch of desserts for birthdays, wedding or baby showers.
- PERFORMANCE: The durable construction of this muffin pan is designed to spread heat throughout the pan, ensuring your mini treats bake evenly. The large handles make this pan easy to transfer to and from the oven, even while wearing oven mitts
- NON- STICK: No matter what you're making, the durable non-stick and scratch-resistant coating on our muffin pan and allows your food to slide or pop out easily, making cleanup almost effortless
- CARE INSTRUCTIONS: This Wilton muffin pan is dishwasher safe; however for best results, wash in warm, soapy water before first and after each use
- INCLUDES: 2 muffin pans, each pan has 6 cups each and fits standard baking cups. Cavity size: 2 in. dia. x 1.25 in. (5 cm diam x 3.2 cm). Limited 5-year warranty
4. OvenStuff Non-Stick 6 Cup Jumbo Muffin Pan
Our penultimate recommendation is the OvenStuff Non-Stick 6 Cup Jumbo Muffin Pan which provides plenty of versatility so you can make muffins, cupcakes and other treats. The jumbo size is perfect for those who want to create giant muffins in smaller batches.
Made from superior non-stick materials, the DuraGlide coating means that the muffins will release effortlessly from the pan while making the cleaning up process easier and quicker.
This also helps to prevent the goods from sticking and breaking while you are trying to take them out the pan.
This muffin pan is made from durable steel which is guaranteed to withstand years of heavy duty use. The spaced out cavities allow you to create equal portions that will form a consistent shape while also being baked throughout evenly.
This muffin pan has been manufactured in the USA and has been made without any PFOA. It also comes with a 5 year limited warranty to give you peace of mind.
Pros
- Made from superior non-stick materials, the DuraGlide coating means that the muffins will release effortlessly from the pan while making the cleaning up process easier and quicker
- The spaced out cavities allow you to create equal portions that will form a consistent shape while also being baked throughout evenly
- Comes with a 5 year limited warranty to give you peace of mind
Cons
- The tray won’t fit in smaller ovens
- ENDLESS POSSIBLITIES: With OvenStuff Nonstick 6-cup Jumbo Muffin Pan you can make a wide variety of jumbo muffins, cupcakes, appetizers and more.
- JUMBO SIZING: The external dimensions of the pan measures 12.7-inch by 8.5-inch by 1.7-inch. Each muffin bakes to 3.5-inch in diameter. It’s the perfect choice for large muffins, cupcakes, mini cakes and much more.
- SUPERIOR NONSTICK: Proprietary DuraGlide PLUS nonstick finish helps muffins release effortlessly from pan while making cleanup easy. Unlike uncoated pans, our nonstick version prevents baked goods from sticking, stopping baking disasters in their tracks.
- STURDY CONSTRUCTION: OvenStuff is made with durable steel that heats evenly with no hot spots producing beautiful golden baking results.
5. Silicone Designs Texas Muffin Pans
Our final selection is the Silicone Designs Texas Muffin Pans which features a set of 2 pans that are multi-purpose thanks to their versatile use.
Suitable for baking muffins, cupcakes, and other delicious treats, these pans allow you to bake in bulk which is ideal for small business owners and avid bakers.
Made from commercial-grade silicone, this is the best choice for those who want a more eco-friendly material and want to venture away from purchasing a metal pan.
The built-in stability bars provide maximum stability, strength, and silicone flexibility which allows you to maintain control of the tray at all times while taking the pan in and out of the oven.
Coming as a set of two pans, you can make a batch of muffins at a time which is ideal for small gatherings and bake sales. The material is free from BPA or fillers which meet the food-grade standards.
The silicone is easy to clean thanks to its flexibility. This pan comes with a free extended warranty with online product registration so you can be assured of the quality and longevity of the product.
Pros
- Made from commercial-grade silicone, this is the best choice for those who want a more eco-friendly material and want to venture away from purchasing a metal pan
- The built-in stability bars provide maximum stability, strength, and silicone flexibility which allows you to maintain control of the tray at all times while taking the pan in and out of the oven
- Comes with a free extended warranty with online product registration so you can be assured of the quality and longevity of the product
Cons
- The muffins can be difficult to remove from the tray
- SET OF 2 - MULTI-PURPOSE SILICONE PANS. Silicone is flexible. You do NOT need to use paper cups with these Silicone Muffin Pans.
- MULTIPLE USES: Large Muffins, Cupcakes, Cheesecake Bites, Mini Pot Pies, Baked Oatmeal, Large Ice Cubes, DIY Soap & More.
- COMMERCIAL GRADE, PROFESSIONAL USE. 100% Customer Satisfaction Guarantee
- FREE Extended Warranty with Online Product Registration
- SET of 2 - Outside Dimensions: 10.75 x 7.25 inches (each).
Best Muffin Pan Buyer’s Guide
When researching which muffin pan is the best one for you. There are certain factors that you need to consider before making your final decision. Before purchasing the pan, always think about the size of the pan, the material it is made from, any warranty or return policies it may have and your budget.
Once you’ve weighed these up against your own criteria, you’ll be in a position where you can make a fully informed decision with confidence.
Size
The first factor you need to consider is the size of the muffin pan. It goes without saying that some are larger than others and if they have larger cavities, they tend to come in packs of two.
Think about how big you want to bake your muffins and you’ll have any idea of where to start when looking at the trays. Some pans have smaller cavities but will be able to carry a lot more muffins.
Material
The material of the muffin pan is another important factor that you should think about. A lot of muffin pans are made from non-stick metal surfaces that help to prevent any breakage to the muffins.
There are other muffin pans that are made from silicone which is a more eco-friendly option as well as being safer to handle when the muffins are baked.
Warranty
The next thing you should always check is whether the pan comes with a warranty or returns policy to give you extra peace of mind.
Most brands have a dedicated customer service who are specially trained to help you should you need any assistance. As you can see from this article, some pans come with warranties that last for years so you can be assured that the product is going to last a long time.
Budget
Lastly, always think about your budget. As with any kitchen equipment, muffin pans can run up to very expensive price points; however, as you can see from the recommendation in this article, there are plenty of high quality options available at varying price points.
Whether you have the money to spend or are working with a stricter budget, you’ll be able to find the perfect muffin pan for you without compromising your bank account.
Frequently Asked Questions
There are not that many differences between a muffin pan and a cupcake pan but the way they are placed in the pan itself is different. For cupcakes, always use a liner or cupcake case before scooping in the mixture whereas this isn’t required with muffins.
Muffins can be baked without a muffin tray by using a greased baking pan to help the mixture to stay in place. However, bear in mind that the end results will not look muffin shaped as the muffin pan helps it to rise and form the signature muffin shape.
Join the Discussion