If you are wanting to venture into the world of baking then there is no better place to start than brownies. Easy to make with delicious results, brownies are a popular dish and a favorite among many.
However, the secret to making the perfect brownies is having a suitable pan where they can have an even and consistent bake to give that signature chewy texture.
Jump to:
Bestselling Brownie Pans
Here, we have gathered the top five brownie pans on the market that you should consider followed by an exclusive Buyers Guide and FAQ so you know what to look out for when conducting your own research.
Here are the top five brownie pans you should consider:
Comparison Table
Best Brownie Pan
1. Wilton Brownie Bar Pan
Our top recommendation is the Wilton Brownie Bar Pan which allows you to bake individual brownies and other treats. Featuring twelve cavities so you can make a dozen, snack size brownies that have smooth sides and crisp edges.
Perfect for those who want to make brownies that are even and portioned, this pan is ideal for small business owners and avid bakers.
This pan allows you to add various toppings to your brownies with ease such as nuts and candies. The non-stick coating makes it easy to remove the brownies without having any excess or breakage in the cake.
What makes this pan our top choice is the heavy duty materials that the pan is made from. The heavy duty aluminum can be cooked at high temperatures without suffering in condition or performance.
The sturdy structure prevents any leakage from occurring while preparing the brownies and the even cavities mean that you can be assured of a sleek and professional looking finish.
Pros
- Featuring twelve cavities so you can make a dozen, snack size brownies that have smooth sides and crisp edges
- The non-stick coating makes it easy to remove the brownies without having any excess or breakage in the cake
- The heavy duty aluminum can be cooked at high temperatures without suffering in condition or performance
Cons
- Some remnants can stick
- READY, SET, BAKE: Create charming single-serving desserts like brownies with crisp edges, miniature cakes, fruit bars, and more with our Wilton Brownie Pan
- TOOLS FOR YOUR CREATIVITY: The Wilton Fluted tube brownie pan lets you get creative with your cooking and baking. 12 cavities for a dozen snack-size brownies with smooth sides and crisp edges
- NON- STICK: To bake your favorite food to perfection, start with the Wilton premium non-stick bakeware set. Our durable steel non-stick brownie pan will heat evenly for years of baking perfection
- QUICK CLEANUP: The Wilton brownie pan is dishwasher safe; however for best results, wash in warm, soapy water before first and after each use. If you're a frequent baker, these should be a staple in your kitchen
- INCLUDES: 1 brownie pan (2.5 in. dia. x 1.5 in. deep) with a limited 10-year warranty
2. Baker's Edge Nonstick Edge Brownie Pan
Our second selection is the Baker's Edge Nonstick Edge Brownie Pan which adds two chewy edges to every brownie which is great for those who want to make thicker cakes. This pan fits the standard box mixes with no adjustment necessary.
The continuous chamber structure means that the batter can be spread easily and even portions can be made for a more consistent bake.
The pan is made from a durable non-stick coating and heavy gauge cast aluminum construction for extra durability and longevity.
Made in the USA, this pan also comes with a nylon spatula and brownie recipes so you can get started on your baking ventures.
The design has been patented and has been hugely popular since it was first released in 2006. The interior walls are proven to improve the baking performance as it circulates the heat evenly to the pan’s middle.
The heavy duty materials mean that the pan will never warp and it is easier and more convenient to clean. With add recessed handles, you will find it easy to turn the pan upside down without worrying about making any mess.
Pros
- The continuous chamber structure means that the batter can be spread easily and even portions can be made for a more consistent bake
- The pan is made from a durable non-stick coating and heavy gauge cast aluminum construction for extra durability and longevity
- With add recessed handles, you will find it easy to turn the pan upside down without worrying about making any mess
Cons
- High price point
- THE ORIGINAL BROWNIE PAN FOR EDGE LOVERS – Baker’s Edge is the perfect Edge Brownie Pan that makes every piece the best one. It’s the only zig zag and sectioned brownie pan that adds two crispy, chewy, and perfectly crunchy edges to every brownie.
- GIVE EVERY BROWNIE IN THE BATCH THAT DELICIOUS “CORNER CRUST” - Love brownies? So do we. We think the best brownies have moist centers, a paper-thin crackly crust, and lots of chewy edges. If you agree, you’ll love the Edge Brownie Pan.
- BETTER HEAT DISTRIBUTION, BETTER BAKING – Contrary to a brownie pan with dividers, Baker’s Edge patented - single-chamber - design, allows the batter to be evenly spread during baking, so every serving will be baked to perfection at exactly the same time.
- WIDELY ACCLAIMED FOR INNOVATION & QUALITY – Chosen as one of Oprah’s Favorite Things, featured on the Martha Stewart Show, Cook’s Illustrated, the CBS Early Show, NBC's Today Show, Shark Tank, and many more!
- “IF YOU LOVE THE CHEWY CRUST ON BROWNIES, THIS IS YOUR PAN” – Carefully crafted for heat to circulate around all-edges and with an ideal 9” x 12” size that is perfect for most box mixes, as well as most recipes for 9” x 13” conventional pans.
3. CHEFMADE Brownie Cake Pan
Our third choice is the CHEFMADE Brownie Cake Pan which has been made from food grade silicone coating.
Adopting a thickened 0.8mm carbon steel, this pan accelerates even heat with strengthened edges for convenient use and avoiding warping. This helps to ensure a longer service life.
The excellent non-stick square brownie pan can be achieved using less natural cooking oil making it easier to use. With less baking time and low energy consumption, this is ideal for those who want to be more eco-friendly with their cooking.
CHEFMADE has a specially trained customer service team who are more than happy to assist you should you run into any issues.
Promising a refund or replacement if needed, you can purchase this pan with peace of mind that you are getting a product that lasts.
The twelve cavities mean that you can make a dozen evenly portioned brownies without worrying about any breakage or inconsistencies in the bake. The deep cavities are perfect for those who want to make larger brownies.
Pros
- Adopting a thickened 0.8mm carbon steel, this pan accelerates even heat with strengthened edges for convenient use and avoiding warping
- The excellent non-stick square brownie pan can be achieved using less natural cooking oil making it easier to use
- With less baking time and low energy consumption, this is ideal for those who want to be more eco-friendly with their cooking
Cons
- Can be tricky to clean
- Safe and Health : Food-grade Silicone coating, non-Teflon, no harmful substance release in high temperature ,PTFE & PFOA FREE
- Commercial Grade : Adopts thickened 0.8mm carbon steel to accelerate even heat. Strengthened edge to convenient use and avoid warping. Ensure longer service life
- Easy to Use : Excellent non-stick square muffin pan can be achieved with less natural cooking oil. Less baking time and low energy consumption. Release easier Clean easier
- Make You Chef : Quickly make high quality family dishes, afternoon tea, banquet desserts and other delicacies. Easy to deal with daily cooking, family dinner, friends gathering, festival celebrations, etc. Spend less time and have more fun
- Best After-Sales : CHEFMADE highly value customers' satisfaction and tolerate zero quality issue. If you’re not thrilled with its construction or performance, please let us know. We will find a solution - refund or replacement - that you satisfy
4. Silicone Brownie Pan with Dividers
Our penultimate recommendation is the Silicone Brownie Pan with Dividers which is made from flexible silicone with a non-stick finish which allows for the easy and quick release of any baked goods.
The silicone is also stain and odor resistant for extra convenience. The all edges brownie pan has been made from 100% pure food grade silicone which is high quality and eco friendly, conforming to the American quality standards.
These pans come as a set of 2 so you can choose whether to make small or larger brownies. With complete control over the portion size, you’ll always have even results and can bake according to any occasion.
These pans come with a tray that has 12 cavities and the other has 24. This means that you have a lot of scope to be versatile with your cooking making it perfect for those who like to experiment with their cooking.
The silicone baking mold is suitable for the dishwasher and can also be easily cleaned with warm soap water making it convenient for those who don’t want to waste lots of time trying to maintain the product.
Pros
- Made from flexible silicone with a non-stick finish which allows for the easy and quick release of any baked goods
- The all edges brownie pan has been made from 100% pure food grade silicone which is high quality and eco friendly, conforming to the American quality standards
- The silicone baking mold is suitable for the dishwasher and can also be easily cleaned with warm soap water making it convenient
Cons
- Not a perfect square shape
- Non-Stick Brownie Pans: The flexible silicone and non-stick finish allow to easy and quick release of baked goods and desserts.
- Safety Material: The all edges brownie pan is made of 100 % pure food grade silicone. The silicone baking molds is high-quality and eco-friendly, conforms to the American quality standard.
- Brownie Pans Dimension: 11.2x7.3x1.0 inch (12 Cavity), 12.9x7.5x0.6 inch (24 Cavity);Cavity Size: 2x2x1 inch (12 Cavity),1.5x1.5x0.6 inch (24 Cavity)
- Easy To Clean: The silicone baking mold suitable for dishwasher, and it can be easily clean with warm soap water.
- Note: The silicone molds for baking can be use at -20 °F ~ 450 °F (-30 °C ~ 230 °C), Microwave & Oven safe.
5. GOTHAM STEEL Nonstick Baking Pan
Our final selection is the GOTHAM STEEL Nonstick Baking Pan which has been made from heavyweight aluminized steel that resists warping for superior heat conduction and even baking.
Featuring a super strong surface that is durable and long lasting, this pan will see you through many bakes.
This pan uses non-stick coating and platinum-5X5-layer spraying technology and is non-corrosive and stain resistant so you don’t need to worry about your brownies breaking when removing them from the pan.
Designed to be multi purpose with a pre-cut divider feature so you can make 18 even brownies, this pan is versatile so you can make an array of different treats.
This pan is easy to use and maintain thanks to the detachable structure which means it is fast cleaning as well as dishwasher safe. With fast and even heating, you can be assured that your food will have a consistent bake.
The pan is non-stick, non-corrosive and stain resistant which means that you can be assured of high quality results every time.
The brownie pan edge and cutter finish is constructed from high carbon steel material which means that it can transfer faster for even heat distribution
Pros
- Has been made from heavyweight aluminized steel that resists warping for superior heat conduction and even baking
- Uses non-stick coating and platinum-5X5-layer spraying technology and is non-corrosive and stain resistant so you don’t need to worry about your brownies breaking
- Designed to be multi purpose with a pre-cut divider feature so you can make 18 even brownies, this pan is versatile so you can make an array of different treats
Cons
- Small leaks can occur
- PREMIUM MATERIAL- Brooklyn Brownie Pan is made from heavy-weight aluminized steel that resists warping for superior heat conduction and even baking, super-strong surface, durable and long-lasting.
- 100% NON-STICK- Brooklyn Brownie Pan uses non-stick coating and platinum-5X5-layer spraying technology, non-stick, non-corrosive, stain-resistant, so you will no longer worry about breaking your brownies when taking them out from the brownie baking pan, suitable for all oven types.
- MULTI-PURPOSE & PRECUT DIVIDER FEATURE DESIGN- Brooklyn Brownie Pan, good for more than just baking brownie, also can be used to make mini cakes and square pizzas, or roast other food when removing the divider. Brownie Mold Pan with a removable divider to create 18 perfectly sliced brownies, don't have to hassle to cut a piece, What’s more, you can even bake different cakes or food in 18 cavities in one pan.
- EASY TO USE & FAST CLEAN & DISHWASHER SAFE- Because of the detachable structure, Brooklyn Brownie Pan is easy to clean, even the corner also can be cleaned out, easier for you to clean up and bake delicious all corners brownies. Brooklyn Brownie Pan is dishwasher safe, with no nooks and crannies, making clean up fast and easy however hand washing is recommended to extend the product life. Usually, a soft sponge or kitchen brush will remove baked-on food particles. Dry thoroughly before storing!
- FAST AND EVEN HEATING & NO OVER CHARRED BURNT- Brooklyn Brownie Pan is non-stick, non-corrosive, stain-resistant, long-lasting nonstick promotes excellent food release. Our brownie pan edge and brownie cutter finish with high-carbon steel material, which can transfer faster providing even heat distribution, in case of the situation that some brownies are just baked right while others are no over charred or burnt, which is very important for baking perfect edge brownies.
Best Brownie Pan Buyer’s Guide
When conducting your own research, there are certain factors that you should always consider before making your final decision to prevent any disappointment. These are: the size of the pan, the material it is made from, the versatility of the product and your budget.
Once you’ve weighed these factors up against your own criteria, you’ll be in a position where you can make a decision with confidence.
Size
The first thing you should look out for is the size of the pan. This is important as it will determine whether it can fit into your oven in the first place. Brownie pans can be quite large so make sure it is a suitable size.
Also, consider the depth of the pan as well as some options are quite shallow meaning that the brownies will be quite thin.
Material
The next factor you should look into is the material that the pan is made from. Brownie pans are available in different materials which all have their advantages and disadvantages.
Most pans available on the market tend to be metal as they have the durability and longevity you would expect. However, silicone trays have seen a rise in popularity thanks to their non-stick nature.
Versatility
The versatility of the product is important if you like to bake an array of goods. Brownie pans are great for all kinds of baking so choose a pan that is capable of giving you even more for your money’s worth.
Budget
Lastly, always think about your budget. As you can see from the recommendations, there are plenty of high-quality options available at all price points so whether you have the money to spend or are working with a stricter budget, you’ll be able to find the perfect option for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Glass pans are often used to make brownies, however, you will have to alter the temperature by reducing the recommended heat by 25 degrees to ensure that the brownies are not overbaked.
There are pros and cons to both pans. Metal pans heat up quickly so they need to be monitored closely to prevent any overbaking. However, they produce flavorsome, chewy brownies when cooked correctly.
Glass pans allow for even heat distribution which means that the brownies will be baked consistently throughout. However, it may be harder to evenly cut the brownies afterward.
Join the Discussion